People's Stories Freedom

View previous stories


An appeal to do away with non-consensual psychiatric treatment
by Catalina Devandas-Aguilar, Dainius Puras
 
The United Nations Special Rapporteurs on the rights of persons with disabilities, Catalina Devandas-Aguilar, and on the right to health, Dainius Puras, today called on States to eradicate all forms of non-consensual psychiatric treatment.
 
Speaking ahead of World Mental Health Day, the independent experts urged Governments to put an end to arbitrary detention, forced institutionalisation and forced medication, in order to ensure that persons with developmental and psychosocial disabilities are treated with dignity and their human rights respected.
 
“Locked in institutions, tied down with restraints, often in solitary confinement, forcibly injected with drugs and overmedicated, electroshocked, are only few illustrations of the ways in which persons with disabilities, or those perceived to be so, are treated without their consent, with severe consequences for their physical and mental integrity.
 
Globally, persons with developmental and psychosocial disabilities face discrimination, stigma and marginalization and are subject to emotional and physical abuse in both mental health facilities and the community. And every year, the rights and dignity of hundreds of thousands of people across the world are violated as a consequence of non-consensual psychiatry interventions.
 
All too often persons with developmental and psychosocial disabilities are formally or informally destitute of their legal capacity and arbitrarily deprived of their liberty in psychiatric hospitals, other specialized institutions, and other similar settings.
 
Dignity cannot be compatible with practices of force treatment which very often amount to torture. States must halt this situation as a matter of urgency and respect each person’s autonomy, including their right to choose or refuse treatment and care.
 
Without freedom from violence and abuse, autonomy and self-determination, inclusion in the community and participation in decision-making, the inherent dignity of the person becomes an empty concept. The international community needs to acknowledge the extent of these violations, which are broadly accepted and justified in the name of psychiatry as a medical practice.
 
The concept of ‘medical necessity’ behind non-consensual placement and treatment falls short of scientific evidence and sound criteria. Non-consensual interventions are very often misused and overused, turning exceptions into rule.
 
The legacy of excessive use of force in psychiatry is against the principle ‘primum non nocere’ (first do no harm) and should no more be accepted. The Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities offers a promising occasion for a shift of paradigm in mental health policies and practices.
 
This year’s World Mental Health Day stresses more than ever the need to elaborate new models and practices of community-based services that are respectful of the dignity and integrity of the person.
 
It is a good timing to take stock of the recent entering into force of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities to open a dialogue amongst all stakeholders, including users of services, policy makers and mental health professionals to work on modern practical solutions which may provide answers to the questions brought forward by the Convention’s standards.
 
We call on States to end all instances of arbitrary detention, forced institutionalisation and forced medication, to ensure that persons with developmental and psychosocial disabilities are treated with dignity and are provided their rights to both, have their decisions respected at all times, and have access to the needed support and accommodation to effectively communicate such decisions.”


Visit the related web page
 


When the violence keeps chasing you
by Jesus Serrano
International Committee of the Red Cross
 
Aug 2015
 
"They came into the church and opened fire indiscriminately."
 
"When I heard the shooting in the village, I knew I had to flee to save my life."
 
"I was kept in captivity for six months."
 
These are just some of the stories that people affected by the conflict between Boko Haram and the Nigerian Army shared with me when I visited the camps for internally displaced persons (IDP) in the towns of Yola and Maiduguri in northern Nigeria.
 
The conflict in Nigeria has left thousands dead and has forced more than a million and a half people to flee their homes. Many have been kidnapped, including more than 200 students of Chibok in April 2014. Today, IDPs continue to seek refuge in other parts of Nigeria and neighbouring countries such as Cameroon, Chad and Niger, turning this into a regional crisis.
 
The latest report by the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) showed that this is one of the greatest humanitarian tragedies in the world today.
 
FACES OF VIOLENCE
 
Natisa Mohammed was two months pregnant when Michika, her hometown, was attacked. She was in captivity for six months until she managed to escape during one of the numerous clashes between Boko Haram and the Nigerian army. The stress of her ordeal caused her water to break while she was fleeing. A man helped her give birth and took her and her baby to an IDP camp in Yola. She is still living there, raising her son Auwel, whom she named after the person who saved their lives.
 
In order to survive, Natisa’s husband fled with the other men of the village. She was left alone with their four children, while he sought refuge in Niger for a few months. He is currently living in another IDP camp in Maiduguri.
 
Natisa dreams of her husband meeting and hugging their son in the near future. However, until that day comes, she must recover from childbirth and captivity, and manage the little money she has to pay for food and water, visits to the paediatrician and mosquito nets to avoid malaria.
 
Natisa suffers when she remembers the violence that she witnessed and the faces of the people who died during the various attacks. She also wishes she could send her other four children, who came with her to the camp for displaced people in Yola, to school.
 
In the next-door shelter built by the ICRC, Swyiman Sanusi, a polite, humble man, is living with his family. Despite the ordeal he has gone through, he never loses his smile.
 
A teacher in Gulak and a father to five children, Swyiman saw his life change completely on the afternoon of Friday, 5 September 2014. On his way home from work, he began to hear gunshots and then saw bombs falling around him. Arms carriers came looking for the men of the village, so his wife asked him to flee immediately. Swyiman had to walk more than 100 kilometers with hardly any food and water until he arrived in the town of Mubi.
 
Swyiman tells me that, while he was hiding in the bushes, he repeatedly thought of turning back to be with his family. He felt like a coward. After trekking more than 15 kilometers, scared, alone and in the middle of the mountain, soaked by the rain, he decided to turn around. At that moment, he received a call from his wife, Maria. He could hear shotguns in the background as he told her he was heading back. But Maria would not let him. She encouraged him to keep going and told him that they were going to reach him soon. Maria and the children were getting ready to run away as soon as they had the opportunity.
 
Maria managed to escape before dawn on 9 September 2014 with three of her five children. The other two went missing on the day their village was attacked. She walked with her three children for three more days under the heavy rain until they reached the main road and found a van heading to Mubi. There she found her husband and discovered that a man had brought her two other children, whom he found crying on the road.
 
The Sanusi family lived in Mubi until 29 October 2014, when they were again forced to flee after violence broke out. Swyiman and Maria, along with their five children, trekked over 400 kilometers, climbing mountains on foot, without much water or food to seek refuge in Cameroon. They settled in an area with more than 400,000 people all affected by the violence in Nigeria.
 
Cameroonian authorities provided the Sanusi family with water, food and a place to sleep. A few weeks later, they were taken to an IDP camp in Yola, where they have been living for nine months and receiving assistance from the ICRC.
 
The Sanusi family are managing to get by because Swyiman is still receiving his salary from the Nigerian government even though he is no longer working due to the state of emergency in the north. The government continues to pay salaries as a form of assistance for people displaced by the violence. However, his salary, 20.000 Naira (US$ 100), is not enough to give his family a comfortable life in the IDP camp, so Swyiman has been trying to start a small business to better support his family and other people in the camp. Every week, he gathers all the children in the camp and gives lectures so they can continue with their education.
 
Swyiman is aware of the severity of the conflict and continues to be grateful for the support he and his family are receiving from the ICRC. In some places, the Red Cross is one of the few international organizations present on the ground since the conflict began. So far this year, the ICRC has distributed food and household necessities to more than 260,000 people in Northeastern Nigeria and 65,000 people in Niger.
 
But the dimensions of the conflict are increasing and the needs are growing exponentially. Therefore, the ICRC has increased its budget by $60 million, which is more than double its humanitarian response across the four affected countries. This has made this region the third largest humanitarian activity of the ICRC worldwide, just after Syria and South Sudan.
 
The ICRC aims to provide access to food and basic necessities to over half a million displaced people in the region, improve access to drinking water and sanitation, and provide medical assistance and surgical equipment in emergency zones.
 
With the close arrival of the rainy season, the situation will bring new challenges, such as the threat of more diseases. It is therefore important to act quickly to improve basic sanitary and hygiene conditions, and alleviate the suffering of the victims of one of the biggest conflicts that Africa is facing at this time.
 
The recent peaceful elections have improved people"s expectations for the country. However, the incessant violence in Maiduguri and Yola, the distant but constant sound of gunfire, and the attacks to nearby villages continue to remind us that the conflict is still very much alive.
 
This conflict is having a devastating effect on many small communities in northern Nigeria. Buildings, roads and homes have been destroyed. The livelihoods of hundreds of families have been lost, and the dignity of those affected has been stripped. Deep physical and emotional wounds have been inflicted on the civilian population.
 
Every member of the international community has a fundamental role to play in helping to heal those wounds. We must increase efforts to come up with a lasting solution to this conflict so that displaced people can return home and resume a dignified and peaceful life in their communities.
 
* Jesus Serrano Redondo is an international delegate at the International Committee of the Red Cross: http://www.icrc.org/en/document/nigeria-massive-long-term-effort-needed-tackle-humanitarian-crisis-north http://www.unicef.org/infobycountry/nigeria_82739.html http://www.icrc.org/en/lake-chad-crisis-missing-family-hungry-children-uncertain-future


Visit the related web page
 

View more stories

Submit a Story Search by keyword and country Guestbook